If you are the owner of the 12th overall pick in a 1QB, PPR fantasy football draft in 2024, you have several strong options to build your team around.
Whether you’re targeting a wide receiver or running back, this draft position allows you to secure an anchor player with league-winning fantasy value.
Using a combination of Sleeper‘s ADP and Pro Football Network’s Fantasy Football Rankings, we will examine three potential players who could be available at twelfth overall.
Which Players Should You Consider Picking No. 12 Overall?
WHO SHOULD BE WHICH PICK?: 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | 6th | 7th | 8th | 9th | 10th | 11th
A.J. Brown, WR, Philadelphia Eagles (Above ADP)
2024 Expectations: Brown is currently ranked as WR6 with an ADP of ninth overall, according to Pro Football Network’s fantasy rankings and Sleeper ADP. Brown has been dominant since joining the Eagles, consistently producing top-tier WR1 numbers.
2023 Data: Last season, Brown finished with 88 receptions for 1,496 yards and 11 touchdowns, averaging 17.4 fantasy points per game. His target share was 28.0%, and he ranked fourth in the league in receiving yards. Despite competing for targets with DeVonta Smith, Brown’s role as the primary red-zone target in Philadelphia’s offense is well-established.
Argument: Drafting Brown at 12th overall feels like the perfect spot. His ability to deliver explosive plays and his strong connection with Jalen Hurts make him a high-ceiling option. Even with the presence of DeVonta Smith, Brown’s role as the WR1 in an Eagles offense that is expected to be one of the best in 2024 makes Brown an intriguing first-round option.
Puka Nacua, WR, Los Angeles Rams (At ADP)
2024 Expectations: Nacua enters the 2024 season following a historic rookie year. He is currently being drafted as WR7 with an ADP of 14th overall. Despite the presence of Cooper Kupp, Nacua has solidified his role as a key weapon in the Rams’ offense.
The Data: In 2023, Nacua finished with 105 receptions for 1,486 yards and 10 touchdowns on 160 targets. He ranked fourth in receiving yards and sixth in targets, averaging 18.9 fantasy points per game. His production was consistent, even after Kupp returned from injury, maintaining a target share of 26.7% during that span.
Argument: Nacua offers a high floor and high ceiling as a WR1 in the Rams’ offense, making him a strong pick at his current ADP. While Kupp’s presence might slightly cap his upside, Nacua’s ability to excel in Sean McVay’s system ensures he remains a valuable fantasy asset. Drafting Nacua at 12th overall aligns with his ADP and offers a blend of safety and upside.
Kyren Williams, RB, Los Angeles Rams (Below ADP)
2024 Expectations: Williams is currently being drafted as RB7 with an ADP of 15th overall. Despite a breakout 2023 season, Williams faces competition in the backfield from rookie Blake Corum. However, his established role in the Rams’ offense, combined with his high-volume three-down versatility, makes him a key player to consider.
The Data: Last season, Williams totaled 1,350 yards and 15 touchdowns in just 12 games, averaging 20+ touches in 10 of those games. His yards per carry before contact led all qualified RBs, and he broke a tackle every 11 carries, showcasing his physical running style. Despite the addition of Corum, Williams’ role as the lead back in the Rams’ offense remains secure.
Argument: Drafting Williams at 12th overall might feel like a reach based on his current ADP, but his potential to build on a strong breakout season makes him an intriguing option. While Corum could eat into his carries, Williams’ established role and efficiency make him a valuable RB1 option in 2024.
Who Should Go No. 12?
Deciding who to select with the 12th overall pick can be tricky, and much depends on what’s available at the turn heading into Round 2.
Brown offers elite, league-winning value as the primary target in the Eagles’ offense, while Nacua provides a solid WR1 ceiling due to his high-volume potential. Williams is also a strong option if you’re looking for a high-volume RB1 with league-winning potential.
Ultimately, Brown emerges as the best anchor option, given his alignment with ADP and his role in the Eagles’ offense, which could lead to another top-tier season. Selecting Brown allows for flexibility in roster construction, enabling you to snag the best available RB or WR after the turn heading into the second round.
