The Washington Commanders‘ backfield has talent, but deciding which running back to put in your lineup may be more complex than it looks. Do either of these Washington RBs deserve to be in starting lineups here in Week 2? Let’s dig in and find out.
Looking to make a trade in your fantasy league? Having trouble deciding who to start and who to sit? Check out PFN’s Free Fantasy Football Trade Analyzer and Start/Sit Optimizer to help you make the right decision!
Brian Robinson Fantasy Outlook This Week
Brian Robinson was the lead dog in the Commanders’ backfield last year, which continued in Week 1 this season. I don’t see Robinson going off against a stout Broncos run defense in Week 2, but rather see a path to steady 15-20 carries for 60-90 yards and a 50% chance at a touchdown. That is usable in most fantasy leagues.
Antonio Gibson Fantasy Outlook This Week
I bought into the Gibson hype as a rookie and then again his sophomore season. I also bought into the narrative this season that he would take over the JD McKissic role from last season.
In each case, I was wrong.
MORE: PFN Consensus Rankings
Gibson had one catch in Week 1, and he fumbled. He has a long, storied history of fumbling problems. There’s no quicker way to lose playing time on a Ron Rivera team than to be untrustworthy with the football.
I don’t see Gibson increasing his role from Week 1. In fact, I predict he loses playing time and finishes with a few carries for minimal yards and a catch or two. Honestly, I think Gibson rides the bench for the Commanders, and he should do the same for your fantasy team.
Which of the Commanders Running Backs Should You Start?
Like my colleague Tim Martens said in Week 1, Robinson should be the Commanders’ running back to start in Week 2.
Honestly, Gibson should be on your waiver wire. Robinson likely won’t be spectacular, but he’ll be steady. If Gibson somehow figures out how to be the passing-down back, it won’t be this week. Robinson is the man in Washington until something drastically changes.