Success can be a complex entity to quantify. Especially at the cornerback position, where statistics and box scores can muddy the evaluation waters, measuring a player’s impact and effectively summarizing their contribution can be a conundrum.
Not when it comes to Kool-Aid McKinstry. Success is not subjective when it comes to the Alabama Crimson Tide cornerback. Few players in the 2024 NFL Draft boast the level of production or the personal accolades that he’s accrued over his football career, and he’s ready to deliver that success in the NFL as a complete package both on and off the field.
Alabama CB Kool-Aid McKinstry Brings Success and ‘Exactly What You Want’ to the 2024 NFL Draft
Two-time first-team All-American; two-time first-team All-SEC; 2021 Freshman All-SEC team. The list of individual recognition on his résumé puts McKinstry in an exclusive tier. Playing at the self-proclaimed highest level of college football, the SEC, he’s been a lockdown cornerback whose play has done the talking on the field against some of the best wide receivers in the game.
Twenty-three passes defended. Ninety-three tackles. Five tackles for loss. Two sacks. Two interceptions. His on-tape success, fueled by an alluring athletic profile and a high-level understanding of the game, has permeated the box score.
If drafting cornerbacks in the 2024 NFL Draft was a checkbox exercise guaranteeing success for the following season, McKinstry would leave no box unticked. He has tasted the tangible rewards that talent can bring and is ready to carry on a rich tradition that stretches from Tuscaloosa, Ala., to the NFL. In that regard, he’s ready to transform an NFL team overnight.
MORE: Ian Cummings’ Full Scouting Report of Kool-Aid McKinstry
“I bring energy day in and day out,” McKinstry begins as he describes his NFL-ready skill set and unique selling points as a defensive back during a face-to-face interview with Pro Football Network.
The NFL Draft process is an unenviable slog for prospects, an elongated job interview that consists of events such as the NFL Combine and countless interviews with media personalities such as myself. Nonetheless, that energy is apparent as McKinstry talks about his journey to the 2024 NFL Draft, the success he’s achieved along the way, and why he’s built to deliver in the NFL.
“I bring hard work, I bring confidence,” McKinstry continues. “I bring energy to the defensive backs group. I’m a guy who can play in any scheme, a guy who can do anything at a high level. I’m exactly what you want.”
Capturing the Energy of Kool-Aid
Born Ga’Quincy McKinstry — don’t expect that to ever change legally; “I’m not ever going to ever legally change my name, because that means something to me too” — the Alabama cornerback and 2024 NFL Draft prospect began the transformation into “Kool-Aid” from the minute his grandmother, Brenda Allen, took one look at his smiling face as a baby.
“I told his mom, ‘Look at this boy with this big Kool-Aid smile on his face.'” Allen is quoted by the Tuscaloosa News
The nickname stuck, and McKinstry captured the energy of the well-known and long-standing mascot of the flavored drink mix throughout his childhood, where he started playing football at three and developed a love for the game in the Birmingham, Ala., neighborhood that formed home. From forming nicknames to the 2024 NFL Draft process, the family has played a huge role.
“I’m very blessed to have the support of my family. They’re always there for me, day in and day out, at all my games. Whenever I need them to be around, they’re there. I’m very blessed to have them in my corner and there for me no matter what’s going on. Just blessed.”
Unsurprisingly, McKinstry’s football inspirations as he grew up in Birmingham were high-energy, hugely talented, and ultimately, highly successful. Idolizing Mike Vick as a kid — “Mike Vick was cold” — as his football journey careened toward the cornerback position, there were two standout, successful playmakers whom the young defensive back modeled his game after.
“When I got to high school, I would always look at Jalen Ramsey,” McKinstry said of his defensive back influences. “Just the way he played overall. Also, Patrick Surtain II.”
The Foundation of Success
McKinstry would ultimately take over the lockdown cornerback role at Alabama from his childhood influence — Surtain — when the now-Denver Broncos star declared for the 2021 NFL Draft. However, before terrorizing wide receivers, quarterbacks, and offensive coordinators in Tuscaloosa, the foundation of success was laid at Pinson Valley High School.
A public school in the suburbs of Birmingham, Pinson has provided several professionals at multiple sports while also having a pipeline to the college football level that includes Oregon Ducks duo Tez Johnson and Bo Nix. However, while McKinstry was there, the program was truly a dominant football powerhouse, buoyed by their talented secondary playmaker.
In 2017, 2018, and 2020, the Indians won the Alabama 6A State Championship. McKinstry developed into the top cornerback in the 2021 college football recruiting class under Sam Shade, earning national honors including USA Today’s Best Male Athlete and Best Defensive Player for his performances during the 2020 high school campaign. The standard for success was set.
“Just the people I was around on a day-to-day basis at Pinson,” McKinstry explains how his high school experience set him up for sustained success. “The coaches helped me develop my game. I was able to soak a lot in from the coaches that I was around and take that to the college level.”
“That’s why I was able to play at such an early age, just because of everything that I learned at high school and because of such a good program we had, I was able to carry that over from high school straight to college.”
MORE: Top CBs in the 2024 NFL Draft
An Alabama fan since childhood, McKinstry chose the Crimson Tide over offers from multiple programs, including the Auburn Tigers and LSU Tigers. Historically, former Alabama head coach Nick Saban likes to limit the time that true freshmen see on the field.
However, a cornerback in his 2021 recruiting class had other ideas. McKinstry earned a role with his performances in fall camp, quickly establishing himself as a future star for the Crimson Tide. With his high school pedigree and ingrained confidence, he never expected any less.
“That definitely was my mindset, to go in and make an impact immediately,” McKinstry explains. “Definitely try to be a starting cornerback as a true freshman. That’s what I wanted to do. Being able to do it was a blessing.”
Developing Into an All-American
No matter your level of natural ability, success isn’t a given. It’s earned. Despite an impressive freshman season, there was still room to grow and develop. There’s a thin line between confidence and cockiness that McKinstry never crossed. He recognized there was room for improvement in his game ahead of his sophomore season.
Thankfully, with a renowned defensive-minded head coach in Nick Saban, he was in the right place to receive the coaching that would make him a well-rounded and ready-to-roll 2024 NFL Draft prospect.
“Coach Saban believing in me and getting on me day in, day out,” McKinstry describes the influence of the Alabama coaching on his personal development. “Coach T-Rob [cornerbacks coach Travaris Robinson] also just staying on me. Making sure that I’m doing everything right, that I’m not taking any days off. Making sure that I stayed consistent and disciplined with my technique.”
“I would say that made me feel more confident in myself and helped me become a better player.”
Saban’s reputation as an elite teacher of the defensive back position has been well-evidenced by the plethora of Crimson Tide defensive backs that went on to become first-round NFL Draft selections and top-tier players in the league. Iron truly sharpens iron, and Alabama could have two players selected from their secondary on Day 1 of the 2024 NFL Draft.
“We went into every day pushing each other,” McKinstry says of former teammate, and fellow 2024 NFL Draft prospect, Terrion Arnold and their influence on each other. “Telling each other right from wrong, learning from each other. Just progress. Using each other as someone we can learn from.”
The individual results were spectacular. Between his production and plethora of awards — headlined by All-American honors in consecutive seasons — McKinstry couldn’t have delivered more from a personal level while in Tuscaloosa.
Yet, during his three years with Alabama, the Crimson Tide never won a national championship despite appearing in the title game during his freshman season.
While calling that inability to realize a childhood dream the greatest regret of his college football journey, McKinstry recognizes that what the much-questioned 2023 team achieved against all expectations was the highlight.
“Even though we lost to Michigan,” McKinstry explains. “How we grew and elevated and elevated. When people didn’t believe in us, we still got to where we wanted to be and had every opportunity to do what we set our goals for.”
Ready To Take Success to the NFL Level
From his family background through his early love of the game and time at Pinson to the last three years at Alabama, McKinstry has built a foundation of success that he will take to the next level.
Even away from the football field, he’s a successful businessman with a restaurant called “Gridiron” and a “Tropical Smoothie-style” business. Through his association with VaynerSports, he’s weaponized his name to become one of the first collegiate athletes to strike an NIL deal.
Even when the chips are down, like his inability to run at the 2024 NFL Combine due to a Jones fracture, McKinstry strives to ensure that success is just around the corner.
He didn’t allow himself to get hung up on a missed opportunity, focusing on the extra preparation time to showcase his athletic profile at the Alabama Pro Day.
“It was very important,” McKinstry reflects on his ability to perform at his pro day.
“Just to show that, no matter what my circumstances, no matter what’s going on with me in life or the football aspect, I’m still going to perform to a high level, I’m still going to be me, and I’m still going to do my business regardless of what’s going on.”
KEEP READING: PFN Consensus 2024 NFL Mock Draft (7 Rounds)
While engaging him in a quick-fire round of questions — where I discovered that his athletic prowess extends to bowling, that George Pickens was the hardest WR he covered in college, and that Jayden Daniels was more difficult to face than J.J. McCarthy — it’s apparent that McKinstry is all about his business.
McKinstry is in the success business. He’s built for it and will bring it to an NFL team soon.
Draft with your friends today! PFN’s Mock Draft Simulator now supports multiple drafters during the same draft! Ensure your player rankings are up to date on the 2024 NFL Draft Big Board and you know what every NFL team needs before drafting.