A recent name on this list, Kyle Williams spent his entire 13-year career with the Buffalo Bills, disrupting plays from the defensive line. He made six Pro Bowls in his career, beginning in 2010.
While he might be more famous for his contributions to politics today, Jack Kemp was a legendary quarterback for the Buffalo Bills during their time in the AFL and eventual merging with the NFL. He made 6 Pro Bowls, including five consecutive from 1962 onwards.
Right alongside Kemp, Mike Stratton was dominating on the defensive end during those early Bills years, racking up 3 All-Pro and 6 consecutive Pro Bowl selections beginning in 1963.
Arguably the most infamous player to ever set foot on the gridiron, OJ Simpson set the league on fire as a dynamic running back. Five-consecutive All-Pro and six Pro Bowl selections highlighted a legendary career for Simpson.
While primarily a wide receiver, Steve Tasker made his name on the special teams for the Bills, earning 7 Pro Bowls during the most successful time in franchise history.
Right alongside Tasker, Andre Reed was also making a name for himself in Buffalo, spending a chunk of his time with the team during its four-straight Super Bowl trips. He was a primary reason for the electric offense employed by the Bills and made 7 Pro Bowls as a result. Reed was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2014.
Taking over from the four-straight Super Bowls squad, Ruben Brown played the role of offensive guard for 13 seasons, earning eight consecutive Pro Bowl selections in his career, staring from 1996.
During their time in the AFL, and subsequent joining in the NFL, Billy Shaw was a centerpiece of the Buffalo Bills and arguably its best player. In that timeframe, he made 8 consecutive Pro Bowl selections, starting in 1962.
Bruce Smith is among the greatest players in Buffalo Bills franchise history with 8 All-Pro selections and a 12-year stretch from 1987 to 1998 where he made 11 Pro Bowl appearances as the Bills were perennial contenders under him.
