Alabama CB Kool-Aid McKinstry was a favorite to be CB1 in the 2024 NFL Draft in the summer months. Since that time, he’s gained plenty of competition, but he still profiles well as a likely first-round prospect who could be a defensive coordinator’s best friend in the NFL.
Kool-Aid McKinstry Draft Profile and Measurements
- Height: 6’1″
- Weight: 195 pounds
- Position: Cornerback
- School: Alabama
- Current Year: Junior
Ga’Quincy “Kool-Aid” McKinstry has always had staying power. Dating back to his days in high school, “Kool-Aid” was already making a name for himself on social media. His nickname, given to him by his grandmother, along with his talent, made him a star at an early age.
McKinstry was Alabama’s Mr. Football as a senior in high school, and in turn, he was rated as a five-star and four-star recruit across the board, with no national ranking lower than 27th. His nickname makes him easy to know, but his play doesn’t let you forget.
MORE: Top CBs in the 2024 NFL Draft
The Alabama Crimson Tide has a long history of cornerback production at the NFL level, and that tried-and-true development under Hall of Fame-caliber coach Nick Saban helped draw McKinstry to Tuscaloosa. And almost as soon as he entered the doors, he saw the field.
As a sophomore, McKinstry took over a full-time starting CB role for the Crimson Tide at CB, but he also took over as their primary punt returner. McKinstry earned All-SEC honors at cornerback. His 332 punt return yards ranked second in Division I, as did his 15.8-yard average.
Former @AlabamaFTBL CB Kool-Aid McKinstry isn't lacking confidence heading into the NFL. 🔥#RollTide | #NFLDraft pic.twitter.com/w8yGWH1zzw
— Pro Football Network (@PFN365) April 24, 2024
After accumulating 15 pass breakups in 2022, McKinstry’s ball production was cut in half in 2023, coinciding with the ascent of Terrion Arnold on the other side. But don’t let McKinstry’s production decline fool you: He’s still a high-level 2024 NFL Draft prospect.
McKinstry’s Scouting Report
Strengths
- Has a lean, well-sized frame with solid proportional length.
- Easy accelerator who has an effortless explosiveness to his game.
- Active pre-snap and zone communicator who functions as a glue piece in the secondary.
- Fleet-footed, elastic mover whose rapid play pace allows him to maintain positioning.
- Fluid mover who can effortlessly hinge around to recover leverage and carry receivers.
- Has the explosive capacity to throttle up on demand and elongate his strides.
- Smooth operator with patience and discipline, who uses feet first ahead of precise jams.
- Makes exhaustive use of the five-yard contact window with biting strikes and punches.
- Technical savant with efficient footwork who can use inch resets to keep hip leverage.
- Minimalistic feel for spacing in man coverage often leaves WRs starving for open air.
- Flashes elite processing ability, reacting instantly to stems and breaks in off-man.
- Has the zone IQ and throttle control to monitor over-lapping routes in side-saddle.
- Has impressive eye discipline in zone but can also key in on WR hips to time breaks.
- Instinctive playmaker with swarming ball skills who forces WR to work for passes.
- Savvy run defender with exceptional play recognition, spatial IQ, and tackling ability.
Weaknesses
- Long speed, while good, visibly falls below the elite mark.
- More explosive receivers can sometimes get a step on him launching off releases.
- Doesn’t always have the recovery speed to erase vertical separation on the sideline.
- Experiences slight stiffness at times when attempting to decelerate and hinge around.
- At times lacks elite sink and swivel freedom overtop comeback routes in side-saddle.
- Occasionally drifts too high when adjusting hip leverage in off-man coverage.
- Can sometimes be over-zealous with physicality at stems, resorting to grabs.
- Still finding the proper balance of ball tracking and speed maintenance at the point.
- May be confined to a boundary role primarily, without seamless slot versatility.
Current Draft Projection and Summary
McKinstry grades out as a top-25 prospect and a worthy first-round pick in the 2024 NFL Draft. He’s my CB3 behind his teammate Arnold and Toledo’s Quinyon Mitchell and has scheme-versatile starting ability early in his NFL career.
McKinstry is the lower-ceiling counterpart to Arnold in Alabama’s secondary, but that’s more a nod to Arnold than it is a knock to McKinstry. McKinstry is still a very good athlete with exceptional explosiveness and fluidity, and his short-area twitch and foot speed serve as central components of his game.
In press-man and off-man, McKinstry has the urgent motion to effortlessly match receivers, and he channels that motion through keen spatial efficiency and awareness. He has a natural feel for matching technique and uses his technical discipline and precise, venomous targeted physicality to funnel WRs into corners.
McKinstry is ice cold — always calm and never in panic mode — an apt quality to have given his nickname. And that trend carries over in zone coverage as well. McKinstry is an adept processor who can smoothly adjust and maintain his hip leverage while managing space and tracing routes.
McKinstry doesn’t quite have the top-end speed and burst that Arnold has, and that shows up sometimes when WRs get a step on him vertically. Additionally, there are occasional aberrations with his sink and hinge fluidity when he’s asked to recover on comeback routes.
Nevertheless, McKinstry is a long, smooth, technically sound, and high-IQ cover man with scheme versatility and veteran-caliber instincts and communication. Although his ball production dipped in 2023, he’s still a high-level playmaker at the catch point and an active, reliable support defender.
MORE: FREE Mock Draft Simulator With Trades
With a well-rounded profile across man and zone alignments, McKinstry shouldn’t need much of a runway ahead of becoming a quality NFL starter, and with more refinement around the edges in off-man, he can rise to be an impact starter with a playmaking flair.
Draft with your friends today! PFN’s Mock Draft Simulator now supports multiple drafters during the same draft! Ensure your player rankings are up to date on the 2024 NFL Draft Big Board and you know what every NFL team needs before drafting.