Former DE Robert Mathis spent his entire 13-year NFL career with the Colts and received 5 Pro Bowl selections in his tenure.
Jeff Saturday spent majority of his career with the Colts. In his 12 year journey with the team, the ex-Super Bowl Champ received 5 Pro Bowl selections.
One of the best TEs of his time, John Mackey spent 8 years with the Colts between 1963 to 1971 and amassed 5 Pro Bowl selections.
In his 6 years with the Colts, former OT Chris Hinton had 6 Pro Bowl selections under his belt.
During his 13-year journey with the Colts from 2001-2014, former Super Bowl winning WR Reggie Wayne amassed 6 Pro Bowl selections.
HOF'er Dwight Freeney spent majority of his NFL career with the Colts. Between 2002-2012, the ex-Super Bowl winning DE made it to 7 Pro Bowls.
Quenton Nelson has been a part of the Colts since 2018. In the last 7 seasons he has made it to 7 Pro Bowls.
Former Super Bowl winning WR Marvin Harrison spent his entire 16 years NFL career with the Colts and was selected 8 times for Pro Bowl.
HOF QB Johnny Unitas spent 16 years with the Colts and earned 10 Pro Bowl selections during his time at Indianapolis.
As one would expect, HOFer Peyton Manning tops this list with 11 Pro Bowl selections during his 14 years stint with the Colts.
